The scorching heat (ramadan) comes in "qayz" ?
What is your proof ?
As for you assuming that the solar system is not used,
where did i assumed that the solar system is not to be used ? re-read my post carefully :
Note also that i am not
assuming that the solar based system to be used instead
of the Lunar based system to determine the "appointed time المواقيت" and Ramadan period as i personally know that both of the systems are a one system
and each one has its role
, can the moon shine on at the night without the sun ? i most likely uphold that the "appointed time المواقيت" is determined / known by full moon plus + another celestial singes namely "planet كوكب" and or " stars نجوم" and of course these "appointed time المواقيت" will coincide with a period/season of the year these season are caused by the position of the sun , so logically all the systems : The moonالقمر + "planet كوكب" + " stars نجوم" + " the sun الشمس " will all be in a state while the time of the event come
, now what is the first singe from these systems
to indicate the beginning of the event ( Ramadan , pilgrimage , night of the decree ) ?
So how did Abarham determine the timing? How did he decide when to call for it?? Again, you didn't answer the question. How are the so-called announcements "timing" if they themselves need to be timed??
re-read what i did post previously
The " Al-ahilah / الأهله / Announcements
" are surely not a time mechanism but appointed times
, i already mentioned in some of my previous posts that the guys who announce the appointed times for pilgrimage and other events use a known method
at that time to determine the date/ time of these vents. Those mechanism / singes was known and used
by the other communities who have knowledge from the previous books.
I didn't tell till yet how the announcement of the appointed times for pilgrimage and people uses because i said that i am studying this i may inchallah know it or come nearer to it , if you know tell us so we all have knowledge , this is why we all study this , we learn from each other and we compare our understanding to corrected it or completed it.
did you post anything regarding how we would determine the timing of pilgrimage , can you show me ? i read your post about Ramadan and you already know what are my understanding regarding it especially its time and how to determine it , i didn't complete my study may Allah guide us to come nearer than this in comprehension.